The kind of graphics I do are used for a web site and also for printing with a Roland Versacamm wide format printer.
My question is for graphics for a web site do you design in RGB colors and when you design for printing are you using CMYK colors.
Or are you using one type of color over the other for both purposes?
Thanks Jimmy
We had a long discussion about this earlier this year.
Personally I prefer to work in CMYK, and you've been given a few reasons why from the others.Many users prefer RGB, and it may also theoretically give a better color representation.You must remember though, that you will never be able to print all the colors you see on screen and export to web, on your Roland Printer CMYK, not even near.Therefore I suggest that you either work in CMYK from the start, which will create reasonably accurate printing results, or that you work in RGB and with Proof Colors enabled in Draw, this to simulate what can actually be printed. If you don't, you'll most likely be disappointed with the printing result.
Edit: I see now that you were the original poster in the thread I linked to. Were you not satisfied with the answer?
Ronny Axelsson said: You must remember though, that you will never be able to print all the colors you see on screen and export to web, on your Roland Printer CMYK, not even near.
You must remember though, that you will never be able to print all the colors you see on screen and export to web, on your Roland Printer CMYK, not even near.
I would have to respectfully disagree with you on this one.
Depends on what CMYK colour space you're working in. In North America the default tends to be U.S. Web Coated (SWOP) v2. The Roland printer is MORE than capable of producing a MUCH larger gamut than that specified in the U.S. Web Coated (SWOP) v2 profile. Working in the CMYK U.S. Web Coated (SWOP) v2 colour space really restricts the output that can be achieved with the Versacamm.
The Roland Versacamm is a much different beast than an Offset Web Printing Press.
Dan
So, I made a couple of quick tests.
Printed the PDF you sent, David, using the sRGB color profile on my Mimaki JV33 CMYK printer and RasterLink RIP.I also created a CMYK version (converted the color swatches to CMYK, using the U.S. Web Coated profile in Draw) that I printed with the very same CMYK profile.The printed results were quite similar to what was seen on screen if "Proof colors" were enabled, just as expected.Compared to the vivid colors when "Proof colors" were off, the colors were not even in the same country, also as expected.
There is a slight difference between the printed results using RGB and CMYK, yes, but they are much more similar to each other than to the original RGB colors.
PS. They were scanned on an ordinary office scanner and downsampled because of file size limitation, but I think you get the picture.No color profiles embedded for the same reason, so make sure you use the correct profiles.
Ronny Axelsson said:So, I made a couple of quick tests.
On my way out the door but wanted to put this on your plate. Attempt using sRGB instead of Adobe RGB in your CorelDRAW file and print to the device with a PDF with embeded profile with the device set to uses the embedded profile.
You may find that the device is now closer to what you see on screen with using sRGB.
David Milisock said:Attempt using sRGB instead of Adobe RGB in your CorelDRAW file and print to the device with a PDF with embeded profile with the device set to uses the embedded profile.
Ronny Axelsson said:What would be the difference if I use the same profile from the PDF versus preinstalled in RasterLink?
Raster Link needs to know what the source profile of incoming files is. If it does not know it has to assume something, the version of Raster Link I worked with did use embedded profiles, not sure about your version. What version do you use?
If Raster Link assumes a source profile of Adobe and you use sRGB than the color will be saturated, the reverse happens if the assumption is reversed.
David Milisock said:What version do you use?
Ronny Axelsson said:RasterLink 5.
I believe RasterLink 5 does use embedded ICC profiles. Can you post screen captures of the RasterLink dialogs?
David Milisock said: I believe RasterLink 5 does use embedded ICC profiles.
So, unfortunately, this is as far as I get, and I am still not persuaded that using RGB is the way to go. I need proof.
Ronny Axelsson said:So, unfortunately, this is as far as I get, and I am still not persuaded that using RGB is the way to go. I need proof.
Ok so far I see that the input profile is sRGB and the input profile is swop.
Also try using pure colors and make sure that you use sRGB in CorelDARW when creating.
What pops up when you click condition management?
David Milisock said:Also try using pure colors and make sure that you use sRGB in CorelDARW when creating.
David Milisock said:What pops up when you click condition management?
Send me your privat e-mail and I'll send a proper gray balance test image to you.